
Title: Cinder Edna
Author: Ellen Jackson
Publisher: HarperCollins, September 24, 1998
Reading Level: 2nd and up
Pages: 29
Genre: Picture Book
Summary:
Here's another spin on the classic Cinderella story. Two girls lived by eachother, Cinderella and Cinder Edna. They both have two evil stepmothers and stepsisters that make them clean and cook and anything else they can think of. However, they both approached it differently. Cinderella would complain and not do anything about her hard life. However, Cinder Edna would sing and whistle and she even took on a side job of cleaning parrot cages to earn extra money. One day an announcement came out for a royal ball. The stepsisters had their sisters get them all ready and clean up after them when they left. Cinderella compained that she wished she had a fairy godmother to give her a beautiful dress and carriage so she could go to the ball. And poof! It happened. However, Cinder Edna used her saved money to get a dress and she took the bus to the ball. At the ball Cinder Edna met the prince but she was totally bored by him. Then she met his younger brother, Rupert, and they danced and told jokes and she even told him her 16 recipies for a casserole! Cinderella met the prince and they danced too. However, at midnight, both girls had to leave. (Cinderella's spell would wear off, and Cinder Edna knew the busses would stop.) The princes ran after them, but they ended up running into eachother. Rupert's glasses broke, and then they found the shoes of the girls. Rupert had gotten Edna's name, but the prince never asked. The prince decided to go to all the girls in the area and have them try on the shoes. Rupert went to to phone book and looked up all the Edna's and went to work. When they almost lost hope thye came upon their last house. The prince went in and the stepsisters couldn't fit into the dainty little glass slipper. However, the girl in rags could. The prince took her to the castle to be married to him. Rupert went into the house and wouldn't let the stepsisters try on the loafer because they were not named Edna. When Cinder Edna came up he did not recognize her because his glasses were broken. He asked her to name off the 16 casserole, but when she could only remember 15 he started to turn away. Then she told him a funny joke from the dance, he kissed her and asked her to marry him. Then they had a double wedding with the prince and Ella. Ella, however, did not like her life because she had to sit through lectures and listen to the prince talk about boring things. Edna, on the other hand, lived in a cute little cottage and her and Rupert lived happily ever after.
My Reaction:
This is my favorite twist on the Cinderella story! I love how Cinder Edna actually made something of her life instead of wishing for something better. I also like how Cinder Ella was there too and you could compare the two girls. It helped to see that Edna made the better choices in her life.
Potential Problems:
The only problems that could be in this book is that the stepfamilies are mean to the two girls. Other than that, I didn't recognize any problems.
Recommendations:
I think this is a great story to read to little kids. It would help teach them that they shouldn't wait around for their fairy godmother to come and grand their wishes. They need to work and make the best of their life, even if it's a bad situation.